From: "Pandaman" <----@----.net>
To: <eric_hcr80@hotmail.com>
Subject: Weyauwega UFO
Date: Wed, 24 Nov 2004 01:50:11 -0600
Hello,
I just wanted to get your thoughts on this when I first seen this picture on the site I was like wow! I like to consider myself a believer as does my wife. without telling here what I was looking at I showed her the picture and said what? it is a bubble. I was confused at first but now I seem to see it, it simply looks like someone blew a bubble and it is actually in front of the branches but the reflection of the flash and clearness of the bubble gives it a background appearance. Just wanted so see what you thought about this possibility?
Thanks, ----
Hi, believe it or not this is the first literate question I've had on the subject (and I've fielded many questions..). Thanks for that.
About whether or not this could be a simple detergent/glycerine bubble that someone has blown, I'd have to say that at first glance it DOES look like a bubble that's floating in front of the trees. However, there are several reasons why it cannot be.
First is that then light passes through a soapy bubble, it is bent because of the diffraction. This means that although you can see fairly clearly through the center of the bubble, as you move towards the edges the light gets more and more distorted.
The second reason is similar: if it is a bubble, the reflections from the lights are all wrong. There would have to be 3 lights arranged in an unusual pattern (and one placed in the tree at left) in order to reflect on the "bubble" the way it does - a distinctly triangular pattern. Also, if you look closely at the lights on the object, they are all the same shape: oval, slanting to the right with a notch in the upper left. In order for all of these to reflect identically off the surface of the bubble, they would all have to be VERY carefully "shaped" and oriented. Not impossible, but quite unpractical if you're going to try to fake a UFO with a bubble. Besides, if you used a flash to take a picture of the bubble it would appear as a very bright reflection at the center of the bubble from the camera's viewpoint. A flash would also illuminate the near branches and change the character of the image.
Further, less compelling reasons: I think the object is in reasonable focus, while the foreground branches are not. Also, the object is wider than it is tall. Certainly possible for a bubble, but unless they're large they tend to hold their shape. On close inspection, the branches covering the upper right portion of the object do appear to occlude it.
So, in short, a bubble can't be entirely ruled out.. But I would wish you luck trying to duplicate it standing in your back yard!